Complete Guide — Adv. Liron Yitzhak Elmaliach
Probate Order — Everything You Need to Know
How to obtain a Probate Order, the difference from a Succession Order, what happens when an objection is filed, and how the attorney guides the entire process.
What Is a Probate Order and Why Is It Needed?
When a person dies and leaves a will, the will alone is not sufficient to distribute the estate. Every external party — a bank, the Land Registry, an insurance company — will require an official document confirming the will is valid. This is the Probate Order: a judicial confirmation issued by the Registrar for Inheritance Matters after reviewing the will and finding that it meets the requirements of law.
The need for a Probate Order arises from the fact that wills can be challenged — an heir who did not receive their desired share, or someone who believes the will was not made freely, can contest it. The 14-day public notice period gives all interested parties the opportunity to file an objection before the Order is issued. The Order, once granted, is a final document and the will is thereafter very difficult to challenge.
Contrary to what many assume, having a will does not guarantee a smooth distribution of the estate. A will drafted without legal advice may contain ambiguous wording, contradict itself, or infringe on rights that cannot be excluded by statute — such as the surviving spouse's entitlement. An attorney handling the Probate Order identifies these problems and helps resolve them before they escalate into a dispute.
Adv. Liron Yitzhak Elmaliach guides families through the Probate Order process since 2014. Her work begins with reviewing the will and the deceased's documents, continues with preparing and filing the application with the Registrar, and concludes with receiving the Order and assisting with the distribution of assets. Every stage is handled personally with ongoing communication with the family.
Probate Order vs. Succession Order — What Is the Difference?
Both orders — Probate Order and Succession Order — serve as the "entry pass" to the deceased's assets. The difference is the starting point: a Succession Order is issued when the deceased left no will, and the Succession Law then determines who inherits and in what share. A Probate Order is issued when there is a will, and the will then governs — but only after the Order is obtained.
There are cases in which both orders are required: if the will covers only part of the estate, the assets not mentioned in the will will be distributed under the Succession Law — and will require a Succession Order as well. Also, if the will is found to be invalid due to a formal defect — a Succession Order can be sought for all assets.
In terms of timelines, both orders are similar: a 14-day publication period followed by a waiting period for the Registrar. The difference is that a Probate Order also requires review of the will itself — does it meet the formal requirements of law, are the witnesses not beneficiaries, does it post-date any earlier will? This review adds a layer of complexity not present in a straightforward Succession Order.
When an Objection to the Will Is Filed
Filing an objection to a will is a legal right. Any person who believes they have an interest in the estate — a potential heir, a surviving spouse, a child who was disinherited — may file an objection with the Registrar for Inheritance Matters within the 14-day notice period. Once an objection is filed, jurisdiction passes to the Family Affairs Court.
In court, the proceedings are conducted as a full litigation: pleadings, document disclosure, testimony, and sometimes expert evidence (medical, handwriting analysis). The party contesting the will must bring evidence supporting the ground for objection — testamentary incapacity, undue influence, or a formal defect. The burden of proof is not easy, and many objections fail in practice.
What are the chances of success? The general assessment is that fewer than 20% of will objections succeed in practice. Israeli courts tend to respect the testator's wishes and are reluctant to void a will on the basis of doubt alone. However, every case is different, and obtaining a realistic assessment of prospects from an experienced attorney before commencing proceedings is strongly recommended.
Adv. Liron Yitzhak Elmaliach represents both parties filing objections to wills and parties defending a will's validity. Her experience as a certified mediator also allows her to attempt a negotiated resolution between the parties before the court proceedings become lengthy and costly — which benefits all parties.
Complex Cases — Two Wills, Defective Wills, and Mutual Wills
Two Wills: When two wills are discovered, the later one generally prevails, since a testator may change their will at any time. It must be verified that the later will expressly or implicitly revoked the earlier one. If the two wills cover different assets, both may retain validity for the assets each addresses.
Defective Will: A will that does not comply with formal requirements — for example, a witnessed will signed by only one witness, or a holographic will with a partly typed portion — can still be approved by the court if the court is satisfied that it genuinely reflects the testator's true intention. The court may conduct a hearing and approve a defective will.
Mutual Wills: A couple who wrote mutual wills (each leaving assets to the other, and after the second spouse's death to the children) created a reciprocal bond that restricts the surviving spouse's freedom to change the will after the first spouse's death. The surviving spouse who has already taken assets under the mutual will may be prevented from later changing the distribution of those assets. This is a complex area requiring advice both before drafting the wills and before making any changes after the first death.
Frequently Asked Questions — Probate Order
Answers to the most common questions about Probate Orders in Israel
Free Initial Consultation
Inheritance Lawyer — Liron Yitzhak Elmaliach
Probate Order, will objection, complex estate — contact us for a complimentary introductory meeting with no obligation. 33 HaShneim Asar, Pisgat Ze'ev, Jerusalem.